Sola Scriptura

So, I’ve been listening to this podcast  http://ancientfaith.com/podcasts/orthodoxyheterodoxy . Lately I have had a lot of questions about the roots of my faith and have decided to deeply explore the schism within the Church which has led to denominationalism, the arguments of humanists against Christianity and Christianities rebuttal of same, and the roots of the Holy Canon. Needless to say, that is quite a broad field of study, but as I come to certain conclusions, I will put them here.

The second in the series of podcasts deals with Sola Scriptura mainly. As an Orthodox priest, the speaker adds to the Scripture the traditions of the Orthodox Church. He made some very convincing arguments against Sola Scripture, including that it violates its own prime principal in that no where within the canon of Scripture does it explicitly state that the sole source of divine instruction is to be found within the scriptures. Also, it is quite clear historically that the early Church got along just fine for over 350 years without a specific canon of scripture.

This leads me to conclude that Sola Scriptura, the idea that the Holy Bible as we now know it, is not the SOLE source for answering questions about God. That doesn’t mean that I accept that Orthodox, or any other, set of traditions is the Holy Grail either. Rather, what do all the major Christian sects have in common on this question? The efficacy of the Holy Spirit.

It seems to me that Orthodox/Catholic and Protestant groups agree whole heartedly that Scripture must be illumed to humanity through the office of the Holy Spirit. Orthodox/Catholic accept that the traditions of their branches are the result of the work of the Holy Spirit giving good council to reverent men, who have worked to the best of their ability to answer questions that the Bible is not explicit on.

Protestants prefer to believe that each of us, individually, working within our personal relationships with the Holy Spirit, find the answers to those questions on our own.

Reminds me of the quote from The Patriot “Why should I trade 1 tyrant a thousand miles away for 1000 tyrants one mile away”. Either way, he ends up with a tyrant.

What else are the various Ecumenical Councils except individual men, led by the Spirit worked out in their life, agreeing on certain principals from which traditions have sprung? Where those councils have been in error, such as with indulgences, those errors have been worked out. Are the councils, historically, any more likely to be in error or error free than any individual sincerely seeking the will of God?

I like this line of thought, because it is unifying. One of the clear statements of the New Testament was that Jesus did not come to start a religious movement or a denomination, He came to save individuals and to found a family that would look after each other. He personally admonished us to be of like mind. I can accept, if not personally feel inclined towards, the traditions that others hold dear. In the same way, I ask they accept my own convictions of conscience. Both of us are most likely off azimuth from the true Will of God in some respects and it is in the working out of that faith that we grow the most in our love of God and brotherhood with each other.

Advertisements

About cptcaveman

An Army Major, my family and I are in Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. We enjoy photography, cooking, reading and outdoor sports like hunting, fishing and trapping.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Sola Scriptura

  1. Enoch_Root says:

    excellent post. I tend toward cumulative wisdom of the last 2000 years… the combined revelation of Truth imbued upon great saints via the Holy Spirit. I am very nervous about a single man with a limited experience of one-man’s observations and capacity claiming to know better than 2 thousand years of theological discernment.

  2. cptcaveman says:

    Absolutely. The writings, both canon and non, of men of God are vital to understanding our faith. I trust my interpretation of Scripture, through the Holy Spirit, a great deal but I am always looking to validate that interpretation with the thoughts of other saints.

    Fortunatly, the command is to work out our faith…not to HAVE perfect faith….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s